Comment

Comment by writeslowly

I suspect that if you're not careful with agent memory it creates a danger of agent-driven cargo-cult behavior. I've watched this in my own ad-hoc agent loops where it starts with something basic, like the first agent tried to run some gigantic dependency inspection command and OOMed the local JVM and eventually recorded a workaround (to enable it to run gigantic dependency inspection commands...), and by time I get a few more agents into the loop, agents have written entire paragraphs about testing and validating local dev environment memory configurations that are mostly irrelevant to whatever is being worked on.

In general I've seen other issues like this where small errors and irrelevant comments in the codebase spin out into larger problems that consume annoying amounts of time/tokens. Maybe Anthropic and OpenAI don't notice this because they're in an "infinite monkeys with typewriters" scenario, but it's noticeable to me when the agent in my CLI has been spinning for 15 minutes contemplating irrelevant details

parent writeslowly 1 month ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton