Comment

Comment by charcircuit

So much time has been wasted by the open source community on pointless projects like this.

>Reproducible builds allow people to "have more confidence that the binary you are using, which is actually executing on the computer, corresponds to the source code".

The developer signing the build provides sufficient guarantees. Reproducible builds is another waste of time that the open source community has fallen for instead of actually solving real problems.

>Bootstrappable builds can prevent the kinds of problems that Ken Thompson described in his famous Turing Award lecture: Reflections on Trusting Trust.

So much time is being spent on a theoretical problem. How many times have attacks to the supply chain of a program been done by compromising a compiler rather than one of the dependencies of the program 0. Why is time being spent on attacks which have never shown up in the wild?

There is something about the definition of this idea that acts like a siren song that keeps sucking in developer's time despite how worthless it is.

parent charcircuit 2 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton