Comment

Comment by thomashabets2

> In Rust you pay for it by arranging your program in a way the compiler can verify.

I disagree with this. The sentence implies that this work is done in order to make the compiler happy, where my experience is that it forces the programmer to actually get it right.

I had an "aha moment" when I was frustrated at failing to express my intent to the compiler, and suddenly realised that the reason I couldn't "just say the magic words" was that my object ownership design was inherently flawed. I had to make large changes not to make the compiler happy, but to actually have a coherent design.

So no, it's not about what "the compiler can verify". That's like saying "my lawyer won't let me do this". No, your lawyer is your employee, not your boss. They're just saying that if you do this, then you may go to prison. It's not the same thing.

("unsafe" is the Rust way to go "thank you, legal department, but I'm making a business decision to take this risk. Your concern has been noted")

parent thomashabets2 2 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton