Comment

Comment by PaulDavisThe1st

> I am talking about an industruy you have no knowledge or lived experience with

I'm the original/lead developer of Ardour, a cross-platform DAW, and have been working with digital audio for more than 25 years.

There are no 32 bit ADCs - your SD MixPre's are giving you (at best) 22 bits packaged as a 32 bit float value. The preamps make absolutely zero difference to the AD conversion (though they might sound real nice).

> Surely you understand a recording made at 48kHz has a max freq response of 24kHz and played at half speed that max freq is 12kHz

This is a very naive version of what "played at half speed" might actually mean. If properly and correctly resampled, this is not true.

> And when I load a 192kHz recording to izotope RX I can literallu see the harmonics going up to 96kHz

Well, I'd certainly hope so! But the question is: what are the energy levels associated with the partials above Nyquist? If you recorded at 384kHz with sensitive enough equipment, you'd see partials above 96kHz - but at extremely low energies because ... well, that's just how physics works.

[EDITED to remove AD/DA confusion]

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton