Comment

Comment by hiAndrewQuinn

Imo, the proved theorem is the API. And that's really all it has to be.

If there are other lemmas, etc buried inside that 200k blob that can be factored out and proved and used themselves, so much the better. But denying a machine-valid proof just because it's incomprehensible with what a human being considers a reasonable effort made to unpack it just seems odd to me. I see no reason not to accept the vibe coded blob if Lean says it's kosher except anthropocentrism.

parent hiAndrewQuinn 4 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton