Comment

Comment by drdexebtjl

I really don’t see the benefit of forge federation. Why do people care that completely separate projects run in completely separate forges?

A project’s issues and pull requests are only useful for that project.

The author mentions avoiding multiple logins and searching across forges. The former is already addressed by social logins / federated identity. The latter is not very useful today, on a centralized GitHub, aside from finding leaked credentials and vulnerable code.

In fact, the tiny barrier of entry for contributing in a new forge might be a desirable quality, to filter out low-effort contributions.

parent drdexebtjl 4 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton