If we want to improve cross-platform SIMD, in my opinion we should start by supporting more operations in LLVM IR. Like vector expansion (currently we only have expandload), runtime-known shuffle vectors, pdep/pext operations.
Also, let's stop with the "vector length agnostic" types being the sole option for SVE extensions. I'd rather write an optimized routine for a 16-byte machine I'm targeting and be able to upgrade it in 5 years than have "agnostic" code that wants to pretend like it would work amazingly on all platforms, but the machine I optimized it for is theoretical. I'm fine with recompiling my code, I do it every day. If I have an algorithm that's truly vector length agnostic, I can make the vector length a constant in my code that can change based on the compile target.
Also, let's stop with the "vector length agnostic" types being the sole option for SVE extensions. I'd rather write an optimized routine for a 16-byte machine I'm targeting and be able to upgrade it in 5 years than have "agnostic" code that wants to pretend like it would work amazingly on all platforms, but the machine I optimized it for is theoretical. I'm fine with recompiling my code, I do it every day. If I have an algorithm that's truly vector length agnostic, I can make the vector length a constant in my code that can change based on the compile target.
https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/issues/113422
https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/issues/172857