Comment

Comment by susam

The code in the post seems very similar to the one in my own post from 2010: https://susam.net/sequence-points.html

  int a = 5;
  a += a++ + a++;
I do remember that this particular code snippet (with a = 5, even) used to be popular as an interview question. I found such questions quite annoying because most interviewers who posed them seemed to believe that whatever output they saw with their compiler version was the correct answer. If you tried explaining that the code has undefined behaviour, the reactions generally ranged from mild disagreement to serious confusion. Most of them neither cared about nor understood 'undefined behaviour' or 'sequence points'.

I remember one particular interviewer who, after I explained that this was undefined behaviour and why, listened patiently to me and then explained to me that the correct answer was 17, because the two post-increments leave the variable as 6, so adding 6 twice to the original 5 gives 17.

I am very glad these types of interview questions have become less prevalent these days. They have, right? Right?

parent susam 6 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton