My own take, and it's veering into the Philosophy of Mathematics, but there's a debate about whether Mathematics is "Invented" or "Discovered".
If it's "invented", then it requires ingenuity.
If it's "discovered", then it was always already there, just waiting for the right connections to be made for it to be uncovered and represented in a way we can understand.
Invention requires ingenuity, but discovery does not. So if LLMs can generate truly novel mathematics, for me that settles it that mathematics is indeed discovered, as LLMs are quite capable of discovery yet I don't consider them possible of invention.
If it's "invented", then it requires ingenuity.
If it's "discovered", then it was always already there, just waiting for the right connections to be made for it to be uncovered and represented in a way we can understand.
Invention requires ingenuity, but discovery does not. So if LLMs can generate truly novel mathematics, for me that settles it that mathematics is indeed discovered, as LLMs are quite capable of discovery yet I don't consider them possible of invention.