Comment

Comment by aprilnya

I clicked this thinking “oh, cool, someone finally made a portable version of the Claude.ai* memory system!” Spoiler, no, it’s not it at all, it’s just a “store”/“remember” memory system… as opposed to the Claude.ai memory system, where it doesn’t make the model actively have to write memories on its own, but rather has a model in the background go through your chat history and generate a summary from it.

I’ve found the latter approach to work much, much better than simple “store”/“remember” systems.

So, it just feels misleading to say this can do what Claude.ai’s can do…

(I’ve been looking for a memory system that works the same for a while, so that I can switch away from Claude.ai to something else like LibreChat, but I just haven’t found any. Might be the only thing keeping me on Claude at this point.)

-

*I say Claude.ai because that’s specifically what has the system; Claude Code doesn’t have this system

parent aprilnya 6 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton