Comment

Comment by sarchertech

If you don’t have a very strong mental model for what you are working on Claude can very easily guide in you into building the wrong thing.

For example I’m working on a huge data migration right now. The data has to be migrated correctly. If there are any issues I want to fail fast and loud.

Claude hates that philosophy. No matter how many different ways I add my reasons and instructions to stop it to the context, it will constantly push me towards removing crashes and replacing them with “graceful error handling”.

If I didn’t have a strong idea about what I wanted, I would have let it talk me into building the wrong thing.

Claude has no taste and its opinions are mostly those of the most prolific bloggers. Treating Claude like a peer is a terrible idea unless you are very inexperienced. And even then I don’t know if that’s a good idea.

parent sarchertech 6 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton