Comment

Comment by qnleigh

I feel like it's nice to get the gist before diving into the gory details. The proof works by showing that just within the axioms of arithmetic, you can formally state the sentence "this sentence is unprovable." This has some very strange consequences:

- It can't be false, because if it's false then it is provable, and 'provable' means ' can be proven to be true.' That would be a contraction.

- So therefore it must be true, implying that it can't be proven. Consequently there are statements that are true but unprovable, even just within the axioms of arithmetic.

This is Gödel's incompleteness theorem in a nutshell. Most of the proof is spent developing machinery for doing logic, talking about provability, and ultimately getting a statement to refer to itself all using integers and their properties. It's quite satisfying because it doesn't require any super-advanced math, and yet the result is very deep.

parent qnleigh 7 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton