Comment

Comment by anonymousiam

The main point that I did not see mentioned in this piece is that Deming should only be applied to MANUFACTURING environments, because things like engineering are too chaotic to identify processes or trends in the engineering itself, and trying to control those engineering processes with SPC doesn't really improve the quality of the engineering, it just adds stress, makes things take longer, and probably lowers the quality of the thing that is being engineered.

Obviously, if a quality issue is detected in manufacturing, there may be some steps that engineering could take to improve the manufacturing process and make things stable enough to obtain meaningful statistics. This is part of the Deming feedback process, and part of the System Engineering Life Cycle.

parent anonymousiam 8 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton