dataset: 72.1m trades and $18.26b volume on kalshi (2021-2025)
core findings:
longshot bias: well documented longshot bias is present on kalshi. low probability contracts are systematically overpriced. contracts trading at 5 cents only win 4.18% of the time.
wealth transfer: liquidity takers lose money (-1.12% excess return) while liquidity makers earn it (+1.12%).
optimism tax: the losses are driven by a preference for "yes" outcomes. buying "yes" at 1 cent has a -41% expected value. buying "no" at 1 cent has a +23% expected value.
category variation: finance markets are efficient (0.17% maker-taker gap) while high-engagement categories like media and world events are inefficient (>7% gap).
mechanism: makers do not win by out-forecasting takers. they win by passively selling "yes" contracts to optimistic bettors
dataset: 72.1m trades and $18.26b volume on kalshi (2021-2025)
core findings:
longshot bias: well documented longshot bias is present on kalshi. low probability contracts are systematically overpriced. contracts trading at 5 cents only win 4.18% of the time.
wealth transfer: liquidity takers lose money (-1.12% excess return) while liquidity makers earn it (+1.12%).
optimism tax: the losses are driven by a preference for "yes" outcomes. buying "yes" at 1 cent has a -41% expected value. buying "no" at 1 cent has a +23% expected value.
category variation: finance markets are efficient (0.17% maker-taker gap) while high-engagement categories like media and world events are inefficient (>7% gap).
mechanism: makers do not win by out-forecasting takers. they win by passively selling "yes" contracts to optimistic bettors