I’ve been paying $125/mo (promo pricing for the $250/mo tier) for Google’s top-tier “AI Ultra” subscription for about a month.
I signed up because I’m a power user. I manage large repos, build my own MCP tools, and live in the terminal. I assumed “Ultra” meant “Pro Developer.”
I was wrong. I downgraded to the $20/mo plan today. Here’s why other developers should probably avoid the top tier.
The “Double Pay” paradox
The subscription gives you:
The Web UI (Gemini Advanced)
30TB of storage
It gives you:
Zero API credits
If you use modern AI coding tools like Aider, Cursor, or your own CLI scripts, you still pay per-token for the API.
My bill:
$125/mo for the subscription
~$50/mo for API usage
Reality:
I was effectively donating $125/mo to Google for a Web UI I barely use, because I work in the CLI.
The “official” CLI is broken
I tried to use the official gemini-cli to avoid API costs. It’s unusable for agentic work.
There’s a known, persistent bug where the CLI crashes with a 400 Bad Request error whenever the model attempts parallel tool calling (a standard model feature).
Error:
“Please ensure that the number of function response parts is equal…”
These issues have been open for months:
Broken auth: https://github.com/google-gemini/gemini-cli/issues/11925
Parallel tool crash: https://github.com/google-gemini/gemini-cli/issues/13292
Shipping the org chart
The pricing only makes sense if you look at Google’s internal structure:
Google One wants to sell storage (30TB bundle)
Google Cloud wants to sell APIs (Vertex)
DeepMind wants to ship models
“AI Ultra” is a Franken-product stitched together by the storage team. There’s no billing concept for “individual developer who needs API credits,” so instead you’re forced to buy a data center’s worth of hard drives.
The feedback black hole
There’s no way to get this feedback to someone who can act on it. You can’t file a ticket that says “your pricing model ignores developers.” You just shout into a generic feedback form.
The fix: unbundle the intelligence
What’s needed is a real Developer Tier:
Give me: high API rate limits + API credits
Charge me: fairly for what I use
Until that exists, I’ve downgraded to the $20/mo plan and moved the rest of my AI budget to Anthropic.
I signed up because I’m a power user. I manage large repos, build my own MCP tools, and live in the terminal. I assumed “Ultra” meant “Pro Developer.”
I was wrong. I downgraded to the $20/mo plan today. Here’s why other developers should probably avoid the top tier.
The “Double Pay” paradox
The subscription gives you:
The Web UI (Gemini Advanced)
30TB of storage
It gives you:
Zero API credits
If you use modern AI coding tools like Aider, Cursor, or your own CLI scripts, you still pay per-token for the API.
My bill:
$125/mo for the subscription
~$50/mo for API usage
Reality: I was effectively donating $125/mo to Google for a Web UI I barely use, because I work in the CLI.
The “official” CLI is broken
I tried to use the official gemini-cli to avoid API costs. It’s unusable for agentic work.
There’s a known, persistent bug where the CLI crashes with a 400 Bad Request error whenever the model attempts parallel tool calling (a standard model feature).
Error: “Please ensure that the number of function response parts is equal…”
These issues have been open for months:
Broken auth: https://github.com/google-gemini/gemini-cli/issues/11925
Parallel tool crash: https://github.com/google-gemini/gemini-cli/issues/13292
Shipping the org chart
The pricing only makes sense if you look at Google’s internal structure:
Google One wants to sell storage (30TB bundle)
Google Cloud wants to sell APIs (Vertex)
DeepMind wants to ship models
“AI Ultra” is a Franken-product stitched together by the storage team. There’s no billing concept for “individual developer who needs API credits,” so instead you’re forced to buy a data center’s worth of hard drives.
The feedback black hole
There’s no way to get this feedback to someone who can act on it. You can’t file a ticket that says “your pricing model ignores developers.” You just shout into a generic feedback form.
The fix: unbundle the intelligence
What’s needed is a real Developer Tier:
Give me: high API rate limits + API credits
Charge me: fairly for what I use
Until that exists, I’ve downgraded to the $20/mo plan and moved the rest of my AI budget to Anthropic.