Comment

Comment by tshaddox

This article lists several of the absurdities of the Date constructor, but only barely touches on the most unforgivable one. The example from the article is:

  // Unless, of course, you separate the year, month, and date with hyphens.
  // Then it gets the _day_ wrong.
  console.log( new Date('2026-01-02') );
  // Result: Date Thu Jan 01 2026 19:00:00 GMT-0500 (Eastern Standard Time)
In this example, the day is "wrong" because the constructor input is being interpreted as midnight UTC on January 2nd, and at that instantaneous point in time, it is 7pm on January 1st in Eastern Standard Time (which is the author's local time zone).

What's actually happening here is a comedy of errors. JavaScript is interpreting that particular string format ("YYYY-MM-DD") as an ISO 8601 date-only form. ISO 8601 specifies that if no time zone designator is provided, the time is assumed to be in local time. The ES5 spec authors intended to match ISO 8601 behavior, but somehow accidentally changed this to 'The value of an absent time zone offset is “Z”' (UTC).

Years later, they had realized their mistakes, and attempted to correct it in ES2015. And you can probably predict what happened. When browsers shipped the correct behavior, they got too many reports about websites which were relying on the previous incorrect behavior. So it got completely rolled back, sacrificed to the altar of "web compatibility."

For more info, see the "Broken Parser" section towards the bottom of this article:

https://maggiepint.com/2017/04/11/fixing-javascript-date-web...

parent tshaddox 9 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton