Fair, the em dash comment was a cheap shot. Withdrawn.
The substantive point stands: you've now "skimmed" multiple files, called them all "boilerplate," and haven't engaged with the actual proof structure. The rebuttals section addresses "The Proofs Are Trivial" directly (Concern 9).
At some point "I skimmed it and it looks trivial" stops being a critique and starts being "I didn't read it."
The substantive point stands: you've now "skimmed" multiple files, called them all "boilerplate," and haven't engaged with the actual proof structure. The rebuttals section addresses "The Proofs Are Trivial" directly (Concern 9).
At some point "I skimmed it and it looks trivial" stops being a critique and starts being "I didn't read it."