Comment

Comment by lerno

Two reasons, the second being the important: (1) If I read "io.print", is this "the print function in the module io" or "the print method for the variable io". There tends to be an overlap in naming here so that's a downside (2) parsing and semantic checking is much easier if the namespace is clear from the grammar.

In particular, C3's "path shortening", where you're allowed to write `file::open("foo.txt")` rather than having to use the full `std::io::file::open("foo.txt")` is only made possible because the namespace is distinct at the grammar level.

If we play with changing the syntax because it isn't as elegant as `file.open("foo.txt")`, we'd have to pay by actually writing `std.io.file.open("foo.txt")` or change to a flat module system. That is a fairly steep semantic cost to pay for a nicer namespace separator.

I might have overlooked some options, if so - let me know.

parent lerno 10 months ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton