A good dev isnt necessarily a good writer. Summarising complexity concisely is difficult.
Restrictions lead devs to write to useless messages like 'fixed a bug' rather than messages that are slightly verbose but actually useful.
Most messages wont be 200 chars. But id rather 200 chars of useful text than 72chars of useless text.
The real world is full of average devs that are average writers under time pressure to deliver code. Expecting them to deliver above average commit messages like googles examples is a pipe dream.
Restrictions lead devs to write to useless messages like 'fixed a bug' rather than messages that are slightly verbose but actually useful.
Most messages wont be 200 chars. But id rather 200 chars of useful text than 72chars of useless text.
The real world is full of average devs that are average writers under time pressure to deliver code. Expecting them to deliver above average commit messages like googles examples is a pipe dream.