One problem with this is that it presupposes that the interviewer is skilled enough to spot problems, ask the right probing questions, etc. Casey is definitely skilled enough. I can’t say that’s universal.
Another problem, which TFA hints at, is bias. System Design interviews are often terrible for this reason. If you present me with some scenario that I know is trivial to handle with a single server, I’m going to want to discuss that, but you are probably expecting me to talk about a message queue, a caching layer, etc. Both are valid depending on the situation, but if you’ve only ever known one type, you may dismiss others out of hand.
Another problem, which TFA hints at, is bias. System Design interviews are often terrible for this reason. If you present me with some scenario that I know is trivial to handle with a single server, I’m going to want to discuss that, but you are probably expecting me to talk about a message queue, a caching layer, etc. Both are valid depending on the situation, but if you’ve only ever known one type, you may dismiss others out of hand.