Comment

Comment by madarcho

The task sounds similar to descriptions in the API space. People figured LLMs would be awesome at annotating API specs with descriptions that are so often missing. Truth is, everyone is realising it’s a bit the opposite: the LLMs are “holding it wrong”, making a best guess at what the interfaces do without slightly deeper analysis. So instead, you want humans writing good descriptions specifically so the LLM can make good choices as to how to piece things together.

It’s possible you could set it off on the labelling task, but anecdotally in my experience it will fail when you need to look a couple levels deep into the code to see how functions play with each other. And again, imo, the big risk is getting a label that _looks_ right, but is actually pretty misleadingly wrong.

parent madarcho 1 year ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton