Comment

Comment by romantomjak

Signal keeps cranking out brilliant crypto papers, but from a product perspective, it feels like they're throwing stuff at the wall to see what sticks. We've got post-quantum handshakes, stories and money transfer experiments, but still no SDK, no APIs, no bots. The official libsignal library is undocumented and incomplete. Large parts of functionality are still buried on clients. Don't get me started on "but they have published all protocol specs on their website, go on and roll your own library"! That's not how you run a product. It's borderline negligent for a platform used by millions.

Every other major messaging app exposes something to developers, but Signal is allergic to the idea. Makes me wonder if they even have a head of product because whatever they're doing now is a far cry from a coherent product strategy. Signal is basically a pile of hot cryptography duct-taped to a messenger that's more hostile than any product in Apple's walled garden. And that's from a day one user who's been advocating for them the whole way.

</rant> thanks to everyone involved in building the product <3

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton