Comment

Comment by alganet

These kinds of comparisons rarely lead to good discussions.

Let's instead be focused and talk about real stuff.

Consider https://learnpythonthehardway.org/ for example. It has influenced a generation of Python developers. Not just the main website, but the tons of Python code and Python-related content it inspired.

Why would anyone write these kinds of textbooks/websites/guides if AI can replace them? AI companies are effectively broadcasting you don't need the hard way anymore, you can just vibe.

Arguibly though, without the existance of Learn Python the Hard Way and similar content, AI would be worse at writing Python stuff. That's what I mean by "main source of food", good content that influences a lot of people. Net-positive effects hard to predict or even identify except for the more popular cases (such as LPTHW).

If my prediction is right, no one will notice that good content has stopped being produced. It will appear as if content is being created in generally the same way as before, but in reality, these long tail initiatives like LPTHW will have ceased before anyone can do anything about it.

Again, I don't see a way out of this scenario. Not for AI companies, not for content writers. This is going to happen. The world in which I'm wrong is the best one.

parent alganet 1 year ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton