Comment

Comment by potholereseller

This sounds like a quasi-Gnosticism: the human body is lower and human rationality is higher; the lower as inhibiting the higher; the best for humans is to transcend their bodies by some means (albeit un-stated in TFA). It is a tempting view, if only because the human body seems frail in comparison to rationality.

It is a QUASI-Gnosticism, because it is a form of rationalism, which is incompatible with Gnosticism; Gnostics valued knowledge as a means, not as an end; they wanted to transcend every aspect of the human body, which includes the rational faculties.

Lovecraft certainly isn't a Gnostic, since total transcendance of the physical world would include (as stated above) transcendance of his cherished rationality. And Lovecraft isn't a quasi-Gnostic: his pessimism is paramount to his stories; do any of his characters ever escape the horrors of his stories? Gnosticism and Xenohumanist's quasi-Gnosticism/xeno-humanism are both fundamentally optimistic; the promise of transcendance is allegedly possible for anyone who acquires relevant secrets (in Gnosticism) or uses the relevant means (in xeno-humanism). I doubt that Lovecraft had room in his heart for such optimism; that would require him to be open to the possibility of the transcendance of Irishmen and blacks.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts.

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton