> 4 : Second Order Selves (e.g. cat). Where access consciousness begins. Theory of mind. Self-awareness. Inner narrative. Anticipating the reactions of predator or prey, or navigating a social hierarchy.
Cats and dogs most definitely anticipate actions of other animals and navigate (and establish) social hierarchy. Is this even a trait of consciousness?
I’ve spent much time thinking of qualitative differences between human and close animals. I do think ”narrative” is probably one such construct. Narratives come early (seemingly before language). This lays the foundation of sequential step-by-step thinking. Basically it lets you have intermediate virtual (in-mind) steps supporting next steps, whether that’s through writing, oral communication or episodic memory.
An animal can 100% recall and associate memories, such as mentioning the name of a playmate to a dog (=tail wagging). However, it seems like they can neither remember nor project ”what happens next” and continue to build on it. Is it a degree of ability or a fundamental qualitative difference? Not sure.
In either case, we should be careful overfitting human traits into definition of consciousness, particularly language. Besides, many humans have non-verbal thoughts and we are no less conscious during those times.
Cats and dogs most definitely anticipate actions of other animals and navigate (and establish) social hierarchy. Is this even a trait of consciousness?
I’ve spent much time thinking of qualitative differences between human and close animals. I do think ”narrative” is probably one such construct. Narratives come early (seemingly before language). This lays the foundation of sequential step-by-step thinking. Basically it lets you have intermediate virtual (in-mind) steps supporting next steps, whether that’s through writing, oral communication or episodic memory.
An animal can 100% recall and associate memories, such as mentioning the name of a playmate to a dog (=tail wagging). However, it seems like they can neither remember nor project ”what happens next” and continue to build on it. Is it a degree of ability or a fundamental qualitative difference? Not sure.
In either case, we should be careful overfitting human traits into definition of consciousness, particularly language. Besides, many humans have non-verbal thoughts and we are no less conscious during those times.