Comment

Comment by dist-epoch

When people say LLMs can't do X, I like to try it.

    Q: Complete 3 by generating new knowledge:
    1. today is warm
    2. cats likes warm temperatures
    3.
A: Therefore, a cat is likely to be enjoying the weather today.

Q: does the operation to create new knowledge you did have a specific name?

A: ... Deductive Reasoning

Q: does the operation also have a Latin name?

A: ... So, to be precise, you used a syllogismus (syllogism) that takes the form of Modus Ponens to make a deductio (deduction).

https://aistudio.google.com/app/prompts/1LbEGRnzTyk-2IDdn53t...

People then say "of course it could do that, it just pattern matched a Logic text book. I meant in a real example, not an artificially constructed one like this one. In a complex scenario LLMs obviously can't do Modus Ponens.

parent dist-epoch 1 year ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton