Every so often a developer challenges the status quo.
Why should we do it like this, why is the D in SOLID so important when it causes pain?
This is lack of experience showing.
DI is absolutely not needed for small projects, but once you start building out larger projects the reason quickly becomes apparent.
Containers...
- Create proxies wrapping the objects, if you don't centralise construction management it becomes difficult.
- Cross cutting concerns will be missed and need to be wired everywhere manually.
- Manage objects life cycles, not just construction
It also ensures you code to the interface.
Concrete classes are bad, just watch what happens when a team mate decides they want to change your implementation to suit their own use cases, rather than a new implementation of the interface. Multiply that by 10x when in a stack.
Once you realise the DI pain is for managing this (and not just allowing you to swap implementation, as is often the the poster boy), automating areas prone to manual bugs, and enforcing good practices, the reasons for using it should hopefully be obvious. :)
Why should we do it like this, why is the D in SOLID so important when it causes pain?
This is lack of experience showing.
DI is absolutely not needed for small projects, but once you start building out larger projects the reason quickly becomes apparent.
Containers...
- Create proxies wrapping the objects, if you don't centralise construction management it becomes difficult.
- Cross cutting concerns will be missed and need to be wired everywhere manually.
- Manage objects life cycles, not just construction
It also ensures you code to the interface. Concrete classes are bad, just watch what happens when a team mate decides they want to change your implementation to suit their own use cases, rather than a new implementation of the interface. Multiply that by 10x when in a stack.
Once you realise the DI pain is for managing this (and not just allowing you to swap implementation, as is often the the poster boy), automating areas prone to manual bugs, and enforcing good practices, the reasons for using it should hopefully be obvious. :)