Comment

Comment by swyx

i shared my review inside of the pod with the team (https://latent.space/p/codex) but basically:

- it's a GREAT oneshot coding model (in the pod we find out that they specifically finetuned for oneshotting OAI SWE tasks, eg prioritized over being multiturn)

- however comparatively let down by poorer integrations (eg no built in browser, not great github integration - as TFA notes "The current workflow wants to open a fresh pull request for every iteration, which means pushing follow-up commits to an existing branch is awkward at best." - yeah this sucks ass)

fortunately the integrations will only improve over time. i think the finding that you can do 60 concurrent Codex instances per hour is qualitatively different than Devin (5 concurrent) and Cursor (1 before the new "background agents").

btw

> I haven't yet noticed a marked difference in the performance of the Codex model, which OpenAI explains is a descendant of GPT-3 and is proficient in more than 12 programming languages.

incorrect, its an o3 finetune.

parent swyx 1 year ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton