Comment by jkh1

In my field, trying to reproduce results or conclusions from papers happens on a regular basis especially when the outcome matters for projects in the lab. However, whatever the outcome, it can't be published because either it confirms the previous results and so isn't new or it doesn't and no journal wants to publish negative results. The reproducibility attempts are generally discussed at conferences in the corridors between sessions or at the bar in the evening. This is part of how a scientific consensus is formed in a community.