Comment

Comment by ForceBru

In another post (https://alexshtf.github.io/2025/03/27/Free-Poly.html) the author fits a degree-10000 (ten thousand!) polynomial using the Legendre basis. The polynomial _doesn't overfit_, demonstrating double descent. "What happened to our overfitting from ML 101 textbooks? There is no regularization. No control of the degree. But “magically” our high degree polynomial is not that bad!"

So... are _all_ introductions to machine learning just extremely wrong here? I feel like I've seen tens of reputable books and courses that introduce overfitting and generalization using severe overfitting and terrible generalization of high-degree polynomials in the usual basis (1,x,x^2,...). Seemingly everyone warns of the dangers of high-degree polynomials, yet here the author just says "use another basis" and proves everyone wrong? Mind blown, or is there a catch?

parent ForceBru 1 year ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton