Comment

Comment by ryandamm

It’s open loop in that the measurement of it being in focus is reliant on the subject matter, and a different measurement.

I’m not making this up, camera manufacturers have told me to my face that focus is open loop, period. They can’t guarantee repeatable focus.

Notably the measurement isn’t of the state of the motor/gearing. Furthermore, being “in focus” means the subject matter’s out of focus blur is below some threshold; there is a range of focus states that qualifies — but those seemingly small differences can affect camera calibration, with >pixel-level differences in effective focal lengths.

It’s open loop.

parent ryandamm 1 year ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton