Comment

Comment by mark_l_watson

I have used neural networks for engineering problems since the 1980s. I say this as context for my opinion: I cringe at most applications of LLMs that attempt mostly autonomous behavior, but I love using LLMs as ‘side kicks’ as I work. If I have a bug in my code, I will add a few printout statements where I think my misunderstanding of my code is, show an LLM my code and output, explain the error: I very often get useful feedback.

I also like practical tools like NotebookLM where I can pose some questions, upload PDFs, and get a summary based in what my questions.

My point is: my brain and experience are often augmented in efficient ways by LLMs.

So far I have addressed practical aspects of LLMs. I am retired so I can spend time on non practical things: currently I am trying to learn how to effectively use code generated by gemini 2.0 flash at runtime; the gemini SDK supports this fairly well so I am just trying to understand what is possible (before this I spent two months experimenting with writing my own tools/functions in Common Lisp and Python.)

I “wasted” close to two decades of my professional life on old fashioned symbolic AI (but I was well paid for the work) but I am interested in probabilistic approaches, such as in a book I bought yesterday “Causal AI” that was just published.

Lastly, I think some of the recent open source implementations of new ideas from China are worth carefully studying.

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton