Comment

Comment by aap_

The article reads more like a trolling attempt. Geometric/Clifford algebra is incredibly useful and by throwing away its product you lose a lot of the power of the algebra. It's like saying matrix multiplication is not useful and you really want to be multiplying and adding numbers in various ways. After all GA/CA elements can always be mapped to elements of a matrix algebra. To get rid of the idea of linear transformations and that they should compose just doesn't sound well thought through.

I don't know what sort of crackpots he's talking about, personally i haven't heard of them, only the accusations. If the author can't separate the math from the people who developed and/or popularized it, too bad. Does GA magically give intuitive explanations for all sorts of weird things? no. Can you formulate a lot of stuff much more efficiently and concisely, and does it help gain new perspective on some things? yes, absolutely. It provides a wonderful framework for expressing geometric ideas.

parent aap_ 1 year ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton