Comment

Comment by advisedwang

Is anyone actually implementing the concept of checking hashes with trusted builders? This is all wasted effort if that isn't needed.

I've seen it pointed out (by mjg59, perhaps?) that if you have a trusted builder, why don't you just use their build? That seems to be the actual model in practice.

Reproducibility seems only to be useful if you have a pool of mostly trustworthy builders and somehow want to build a consensus out of that. Which I suppose is useful for a distributed community but does seem like a stretch for the amount of work going in to reproducible builds.

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton