The post links to this GitHub issue [1] where the critic explains his issues with the design and the programmer asks him to elaborate on how those crypto issues apply to his implementation. The critic's reply does not convince me. It doesn't address any points, and refers to some vague idea about "boring cryptography". In what way is AWS secrets manager or Hashicorp Vault more "obviously secure" than the author's 72-line javascript file?
[1] https://github.com/gristlabs/secrets.js/issues/2