Comment

Comment by EncomLab

We should stop using the term "black box" to mean "we don't know" when really it's "we could find out but it would be really hard".

We can precisely determine the exact state of any digital system and track that state as it changes. In something as large as a LLM doing so is extremely complex, but complexity does not equal unknowable.

These systems are still just software, with pre-defined operations executing in order like any other piece of software. A CPU does not enter some mysterious woo "LLM black box" state that is somehow fundamentally different than running any other software, and it's these imprecise terms that lead to so much of the hype.

parent EncomLab 1 year ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton