> But saying "they couldn't replicate it because they're idiots, therefore it's replicable" is not a rebuttal, just bullying
That's not an argument made in the linked tweet. His claim is "they couldn't replicate it because they didn't follow the steps", which seems like a very reasonable claim, regardless of the motivation behind making it.
That's not an argument made in the linked tweet. His claim is "they couldn't replicate it because they didn't follow the steps", which seems like a very reasonable claim, regardless of the motivation behind making it.