One thing I learned about optimizers is some optimizations undo earlier optimizations. The state of the optimized program will sometimes flip-flop back and forth and never converge on a solution. Then you have to rely on a heuristic to guess at the better form, and live with it. The optimizer has a counter in it so it will "pull the plug" if it fails to converge, and will just go with the last state.
My optimizer first appeared in Datalight C around 1984 or so. It was the first DFA optimizer for any C compiler on the PC. C compiler benchmark roundups were popular articles in programming magazines at the time. We breathlessly waited for the next roundup article.
When it came, Datalight C was omitted from it! The journalist said they excluded Datalight C because it was buggy, as it deleted the benchmark code and just printed the success message. The benchmarks at the time consisted of things like:
for (i = 0; i < 1000; ++i) a = 3;
so of course it deleted the useless code.
I was really angry about that, as the journalist never bothered to call us and ask about DLC's behavior. Our sales tanked after that article.
But it wasn't long until the industry realized that optimizers were the future, the benchmarks were revised, and the survivors in the compiler business all did optimizers. DLC recovered, but as you can tell, I am still annoyed at the whole incident.
My optimizer first appeared in Datalight C around 1984 or so. It was the first DFA optimizer for any C compiler on the PC. C compiler benchmark roundups were popular articles in programming magazines at the time. We breathlessly waited for the next roundup article.
When it came, Datalight C was omitted from it! The journalist said they excluded Datalight C because it was buggy, as it deleted the benchmark code and just printed the success message. The benchmarks at the time consisted of things like:
so of course it deleted the useless code.I was really angry about that, as the journalist never bothered to call us and ask about DLC's behavior. Our sales tanked after that article.
But it wasn't long until the industry realized that optimizers were the future, the benchmarks were revised, and the survivors in the compiler business all did optimizers. DLC recovered, but as you can tell, I am still annoyed at the whole incident.