It’s like every single sentence you just wrote is incorrect?
1. You’re making up some weird goalposts here of what it means to reason. It’s not reasoning unless it can access the internet to search for parts? No. That has nothing to do with reasoning. You just think it would be cool if it could do that.
2. “Can figure out stuff without being trained on it”
That’s exactly what it’s doing in the cypher example. It wasn’t trained to know that that input meant the corresponding output through the cypher. Emergent reasoning through autocomplete, sure, but that’s still reasoning.
3. “Forward only”. If that was the case then back and forth conversations with the llm would be pointless. It wouldn’t be able to improve upon previous answers it gave you when you give it new details. But that’s not how it works. If tell it one thing, then separately tell it another thing, it can change its original conclusion based on your new input.
4. Even desolate your convoluted test for reasoning, ChatGPT CAN do what you asked… even using the internet to look up parts it can either do out of the box or could do if given a plug-in to allow that.
1. You’re making up some weird goalposts here of what it means to reason. It’s not reasoning unless it can access the internet to search for parts? No. That has nothing to do with reasoning. You just think it would be cool if it could do that.
2. “Can figure out stuff without being trained on it” That’s exactly what it’s doing in the cypher example. It wasn’t trained to know that that input meant the corresponding output through the cypher. Emergent reasoning through autocomplete, sure, but that’s still reasoning.
3. “Forward only”. If that was the case then back and forth conversations with the llm would be pointless. It wouldn’t be able to improve upon previous answers it gave you when you give it new details. But that’s not how it works. If tell it one thing, then separately tell it another thing, it can change its original conclusion based on your new input.
4. Even desolate your convoluted test for reasoning, ChatGPT CAN do what you asked… even using the internet to look up parts it can either do out of the box or could do if given a plug-in to allow that.