> Speculative execution is so valuable for performance that a computer without it is completely unusable.
Jim Keller's view aligns with this and goes further. My interpretation of his thinking is that predictors and speculation are the only meaningful features of CPUs today. ISA doesn't matter anymore because the power of modern compilers makes high performance software highly portable and all CPUs end up bottlenecked on the quality and capacity of the predictors, regardless of the ISA. For example, the burden of x86 complexity no longer matters because it amounts to a "tax" small enough to be lost in the noise.
That's from a designer making high performance RISC-V CPUs.
Jim Keller's view aligns with this and goes further. My interpretation of his thinking is that predictors and speculation are the only meaningful features of CPUs today. ISA doesn't matter anymore because the power of modern compilers makes high performance software highly portable and all CPUs end up bottlenecked on the quality and capacity of the predictors, regardless of the ISA. For example, the burden of x86 complexity no longer matters because it amounts to a "tax" small enough to be lost in the noise.
That's from a designer making high performance RISC-V CPUs.