The comment you replied to described an edge case and explained why it's broken in that particular case. You haven't actually responded to the example provided.
> it's just not clear if you're going to recall them or not. Figuring that out becomes the priority
Presumably the priority ought to be (re)starting with a small subset of cards and gradually trickling the others back in. The algorithm needs to account for time spent by the given individual and adapt to changes in that over time.
I haven't used Anki for about a decade so I'm not familiar with the current state of things. At the time a major factor in my dropping it was that I found the algorithm to be more of a hindrance than a help.
> it's just not clear if you're going to recall them or not. Figuring that out becomes the priority
Presumably the priority ought to be (re)starting with a small subset of cards and gradually trickling the others back in. The algorithm needs to account for time spent by the given individual and adapt to changes in that over time.
I haven't used Anki for about a decade so I'm not familiar with the current state of things. At the time a major factor in my dropping it was that I found the algorithm to be more of a hindrance than a help.