Comment

Comment by AnotherGoodName

They exist purely to handle control pads imho and the article doesn't mention that. That's when they first started appearing, Secret of Mana, noted in the article was a SNES game.

They do not exist to benefit mouse+kb users. Mouse+kb users are absolutely better off imho with an always on and hotkeyed action bar down the bottom/side. If you don't know the hotkey you can still flick the mouse over and back faster than activating a radial menu.

When you see a radial menu in a PC game you can bet it's because the game had consoles in mind first and foremost.

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton