Comment

Comment by palata

Hmm you seem to be saying two different things here:

1. Words describing concepts you don't like are "slurs". Would you say that "genocide", "murder", "mobbing" are slurs, too?

2. Merely using a word means "forcing an ideology". If I talk about a genocide, would you think that I am trying to force my ideology (which would be... I guess an ideology of genocide, somehow)?

Do I get that right? I'm genuinely trying to understand.

The way I see it is this: there are people in the world who identify themselves with a gender that differs from their sex societally designated/assigned at birth. That is not an ideology, that is a fact. Instead of using this whole sentence when referring to them as a group, the word "transgender" (or "trans" for short) can be used. It is just a descriptive word.

Now if someone wants to refer to the group of people who are not trans, they can say "non-trans". I don't really see that as a word, but rather as a language construct ("not trans"). Instead of saying "non-trans", one can say "cisgender" ("cis" for short).

In my view, those words just describe factual groups of people. I genuinely don't see how they force an ideology (what ideology would that be?).

parent palata 2 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton