Comment by ryanworl

This strategy will not work well for Apache Kafka because it is extremely IOPS hungry if you have more than a few partitions, and a replay of a large topic will require lots of IO bandwidth. It would work well e.g. a columnar database where a query targeting old data may only require reading a small fraction of the size of the volume, but Kafka is effectively a row-oriented storage system, so the IO pattern is different.