Your stylized example is unrelated to reality. Users cannot subscribe to Spotify in app, so Apple makes no money from them while providing all the R&D they use to play audio on the device for free. Next, people say that the hassle of subscribing to Spotify outside the app is an insurmountable friction for Spotify, yet somehow Spotify is the dominant streaming music provider.
So Apple has built all the key innovations which make mobile music streaming a viable product, gives it to the biggest music streaming service for free, and then gets slammed because it doesn’t also go out of its way to allow that service to integrate with Apple’s assistant AI product (except when it does build that functionality, the streaming service doesn’t even adopt it!).
So Apple has built all the key innovations which make mobile music streaming a viable product, gives it to the biggest music streaming service for free, and then gets slammed because it doesn’t also go out of its way to allow that service to integrate with Apple’s assistant AI product (except when it does build that functionality, the streaming service doesn’t even adopt it!).
Simply absurd logic.