Discussion

Ask HN: Is ChatGPT becoming useless for many tasks?

I asked ChatGPT 4 to convert some code using a rather simple pattern, only to get get this message:

> Sorry, but I can't convert this as per your requirement.

Not explanation, no attempt to even do something. Not sure if this is a recent development; I thought v4 was supposed to be even more powerful that v3 (which at least gives me something).

I also constantly have to stop myself from asking it to perform even relatively simple programming tasks. For example, no matter what I did or the hints I provided (including sample code), it could not write anything resembling a correct implementation of the the following function signature:

  const tokenizeWords = (
    str: string, 
    args?: {
      separatorCaseChanges?: | "upper" | "lower" | "all" | "none", // default is "upper"
      separatorChars?: Array<string>, // default is white-space
    }
  ): string[] ...

It could not even write unit tests for the function without making errors in test cases all over.

At this point it quite clear to me that it is more of a time waster than useful. I think the hype surrounding LLMs and AI coding assistants is far beyond the reality. Developers, you can relax knowing that your jobs are safe for the foreseeable future.

18 points prmph 2 years ago 10 comments

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton