Comment

Comment by woolion

Blocking out the values/shapes is one of the most basic techniques taught to start painting. It helps finding the right composition and making sure values are 'correct' by focusing on what's "theoretically" correct rather than what you see. This is especially important as a beginner where it is very hard to access raw visual information from your eyes without the layers of semantic interpretation your brain adds (in simple words, if you see grass your brain will tell you 'this is green' even if the actual color, with the influence of ambient light, is blue or sightly purple).

So to me this article feels a bit like if someone discovered some really basic fact of computer science, like "you can do algebra on strings. If we define + as concatenation, then we can have an abstract arithmetic that works on numbers, strings or sets...". Which would be swell, but I feel the proper response would be to say that this intuition is backed properly by type theory and point out the best textbooks that would suit the author to learn it.

It is a sad state of "art" "education" that everyone has to go through re-learning everything and there are few references with proper learning paths and a good conceptual approach. While you can learn, it is very inefficient and error-prone.

Of course there's another important thing about mindset: in my computer science example, it is hard to imagine somebody up in arms yelling "stay out of this with your technical garbage called 'type theory', it is going to spoil the author mind!". But it is equally hard to imagine this not happening in art.

parent woolion 2 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton