Comment

Comment by NovemberWhiskey

Society criminalizes "victimless" behavior all the time for really good reasons.

Like: if I try and kill my neighbor, but my rifle jams as I shoot, there's no victim, right? Or: if my friends and I get together to plan the burning of a synagogue, there's no victim. Or: if I offer to pay you to kill that pesky neighbour, there's no victim (until you go through with it). Or: if I offer to buy goods off you that have you stole, what I am doing has no victim (the goods were already stolen).

The notion that "victimless" crime is somehow in a category of crimes that are lesser or "not proper" crimes is unjustified.

We have above: attempted murder, conspiracy to commit arson, soliciting a murder, receipt of stolen goods - most of which I think people would regard as serious crimes.

Societies criminalize things that are considered "bad", victim or no - and that reflects the contemporary moral viewpoint of the society. Sodomy (of the consensual variety) was a crime many places, and now it generally isn't.

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton