Comment

Comment by konschubert

I do not understand how this is supposed to prevent sibyl attacks?

How do they prevent fake virtual iris scanning devices from pretending that they scanned a person that doesn’t actually exist?

Or is the idea that sama is will run a centralised private identity system that aims to replace government identity management? Then why do you need crypto?

Are they trying to replace proof of stake/proof of work with “proof of being a human being”? I don’t see how the iris scanning achieves this?

I think it’s fundamentally impossible.

If you don’t have a centralised authority verifying identity, the best thing you can get is peer-to-peer federated identity verification like PGP. But with this, identity is relative, as in “I trust a guy who trusts a gal who says this person is real”.

parent konschubert 3 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton