Comment

Comment by cycomanic

The argument about why not to include the i in 2 pi i is incorrect. The problem is he says (e^x)^i2pi = e^i2pix does not work because ln(e^i2pi)=0. But he needs to use the complex logarithm. And for the complex logarithm ln(e^z) =z for z in C.

If that wasn't the case calculation rules of logarithms and exponentials would depend on if arguments are complex or real, a lot of physics would become much more complicated suddenly.

parent cycomanic 3 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton